← Back to Blog

Understanding the differences between lean and Six Sigma methodologies

minute read
Updated on:
August 25, 2024
August 30, 2024
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Discover Bonsai all-in-one business management software.

The Lean method and Six Sigma are both business strategies that aim at improving processes in an organization but they are different. Lean Six Sigma mainly focuses on the aspects of waste and efficiency, adopting Lean Principles to enhance the operation of the supply chain. On the other hand, Six Sigma uses statistics to decrease variation and defect rates. It uses some formats like the DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control) and DMADV (Define, Measure, Analyze, Design, Verify) and has focused on near-perfect processes with minimal defects.

Introduction to lean and six sigma methodologies

Lean Six Sigma is a management approach that integrates Lean concepts and Six Sigma techniques for the purpose of improving business processes, productivity and eliminating waste. Both methodologies use specific approaches: Lean is famous for the elimination of waste to enhance customer value while Six Sigma is famous for decreasing the rate of defects and the variation of the process through the use of statistics. 

Six Sigma has two types of project management frameworks; DMAIC and DMADV. They both intend to increase the supply chain performance and create efficient procedures in organizations by far.

Defining lean methodology

Lean Methodology is a business strategy that aims at minimizing waste in order to improve the efficiency of a given process. In its other aspects like supply chain performance, it uses Lean Principles to establish good processes. The Lean method consists of tools such as Lean Six Sigma, DMAIC, and DMADV, all of which seek to lower variation and defective percentages in business processes.

Lean Methodology involves the use of statistical tools to eliminate things that are not useful in a process hence enhancing productivity and profitability.

Defining Six Sigma methodology

Lean Six Sigma is an effective business strategy that aims at the improvement of processes, a decrease in the number of defects in production, and the enhancement of service operations. It involves the use of statistical methods in the elimination of variation and wastes, which in turn leads to improvement of efficiency and sound processes.

DMAIC and DMADV are two of the sub-methodologies of Six Sigma. DMAIC is an acronym for Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, and Control and is utilized for process improvement. DMADV, Define, Measure, Analyze, Design, Verify, is applied when it is necessary to develop new processes or new products that will conform to the Six Sigma standards. 

Both are intended to improve supply chain performance and use Lean methods to eliminate non-value-added activities and improve processes. Here are a few interesting things to note:

  • Lean Six Sigma is a business improvement methodology that uses the tools of Six Sigma with Lean to improve processes and minimize defects in production and operations.
  • DMAIC makes enhancements to existing processes while DMADV is used to develop new processes that are of Six Sigma quality.
  • Both of them aim at minimizing variation, minimizing waste, and improving the supply chain.

Origins and evolution of lean and six sigma

Lean Six Sigma as a methodology is rooted in the quality management principles of the twentieth century. It integrates the Lean technique which seeks to eliminate waste with the Six Sigma technique which seeks to reduce defect rates. These two systems utilize statistical analysis in the quest for efficiency and optimum processes. These philosophies have developed from simple process improvement tools to a complete business management concept with enshrined principles such as DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, and Control) and DMADV (Define, Measure, Analyze, Design, and Verify). Application has also spread to areas such as supply chain performance and service industry practice.

The birth of lean methodology

The root of the Lean Methodology can be dated back to the manufacturing industry especially the automotive industry as a business strategy that focuses on processes and value. Some of the aspects that the company uses include waste minimization, process improvement, and eradication of defects, which are all from Lean Principles in order to enhance the supply chain. Lean developed into Six Sigma and thus Lean Six Sigma came into existence. With DMAIC and DMADV as their tools, Lean Six Sigma targets to minimize variation and enhance the quality of business processes.

The evolution of six sigma

Six Sigma started as a tool aimed at enhancing the methods of manufacturing but has evolved into a business management strategy. It employs Lean Principles and methods such as DMAIC and DMADV in order to enhance its business processes. Originally it was oriented to decrease defect rates, but later it embraced processes to improve the supply chain and minimize waste.

In essence, Six Sigma is fundamentally designed to deliver a measured data-driven method. This involves statistical analysis to minimize variation and also to enhance productivity. Currently, Lean Six Sigma is a combination of Lean method and Six Sigma that can be used for continuous improvement in business.

Key principles of lean and six sigma

Lean Six Sigma can then be described as a business management strategy that incorporates Lean and Six Sigma methodologies in order to deliver efficiency. This hybrid approach is based on the improvement of the processes using such tools as statistical analysis and others. DMAIC and DMADV are two of the most crucial methodologies that are used in Six Sigma. DMAIC is an acronym for Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, and Control while DMADV is an acronym for Define, Measure, Analyze, Design, and Verify. Both are targeted at increasing speed, decreasing the number of defects, and optimizing the supply chain. The integration of Lean Principles into this approach increases its effectiveness since it can assist organizations in reducing waste hence increasing productivity and quality. As a result, Lean Six Sigma promotes continuous business process improvement.

Core principles of lean

Lean is a business management approach that focuses on eliminating waste to improve the performance of business processes and supply chains with the ultimate aim of satisfying the customer. The main idea of this method is based on the Lean Principles, which aim at waste identification, the development of efficient processes, and constant improvement.

Tools and techniques used for this purpose include Lean Six Sigma, DMAIC, and DMADV among others. They use statistical methods to minimize variability and defects, make and improve decisions, and enhance processes. These principles are known and accepted as ways of achieving improved business performance. Here are a few more notable things about Lean principles: 

  • Lean aims at reducing variation, and waste, and enhancing the value delivery systems in the supply chain and operations.
  • Lean Principles aim at reducing waste, increasing the efficiency of business processes, and increasing customer value.
  • Lean Six Sigma, DMAIC, and DMADV are some of the tools whose primary focus is to employ statistical methods in the removal of defects and encouragement of improvement processes.

Core principles of six sigma

Two fundamental concepts are at the base of Six Sigma: DMAIC and DMADV. These methodologies help in directing the use of Six Sigma, making processes work efficiently, controlling variation, and decreasing defect levels. They apply statistical techniques to find out and eliminate wastes, and therefore, to enhance the efficiency of the supply chain considerably. This business philosophy is normally used with the Lean Method to form Lean Six Sigma. Building on the Lean Principles, this approach is even more specific to address waste and seek improvements throughout an organization’s processes.

Lean vs six sigma: A comparative analysis

Lean Six Sigma and Six Sigma are two key business methodologies that are based on the improvement of business processes. Lean Six Sigma is a business improvement methodology that integrates Lean which targets minimizing waste and Six Sigma which targets minimizing variation and defect rates through the use of statistical tools. Six Sigma uses DMAIC for improving the existing business processes or the DMADV for designing new products or processes. Lean Six Sigma also focuses on supply chain performance in addition to efficiency and effective processes. Therefore, depending on the company’s needs, whether they require a system that minimizes waste or a system that minimizes variation, then the two are used.

Focus areas: Lean vs Six Sigma

Lean Six Sigma is a methodology that integrates Lean method and Six Sigma to improve processes’ efficiency and effectiveness. Whereas, Lean is implemented to eliminate waste and enhance the supply chain effectiveness, Six Sigma targets minimizing variation and defect rate in the business process.

Two key concepts in these methods are DMAIC – an acronym for Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve and Control, which is applicable to existing processes and DMADV – an acronym for Define, Measure, Analyze, Design and Verify which is applied where new processes are required. Statistics are employed for process improvement with the objective of enhancing the value of the product to the customer.

Approach to problem-solving: Lean vs Six Sigma

The two methodologies of Lean and Six Sigma have approaches to the problem-solving process. Lean Six Sigma is aimed mainly at the minimization of wastage, and streamlining of processes and productivity. Applying Lean Principles to supply chain performance, it seeks to eliminate non-value-added activities from the supply chain. On the other hand, Six Sigma employs statistical tools in the DMAIC or DMADV method of analysis. It aims at the decrease of the defects and variations and offers better processes. Its central business philosophy deals with enhancing product quality.

Role of data: Lean vs Six Sigma

Data is used in both Lean Six Sigma and Six Sigma to drive the improvement of processes that are carried out in organizations. It is the application of statistical tools in the DMAIC and DMADV processes to control variation, increase throughput decrease defects, and supply chain quality. Lean Six Sigma combines the Lean method which is centered on waste minimization with Six Sigma which is centered on process effectiveness. Therefore, data is useful in the accomplishment of these objectives. With the help of data, Lean can be implemented together with Six Sigma’s business methodology for the process’s improvement.

Integration of lean and six sigma: Lean six sigma

Lean Six Sigma is a business approach that integrates Lean which looks at efficiency and speed in eliminating wastes and Six Sigma which aims at reducing variation and defect rates through DMAIC or DMADV models. This integrated approach is meant to eliminate waste and hence drive efficiency and effectiveness of the supply chain and processes. Following the Lean Principles, Lean Six Sigma wants to achieve a speedy, efficient, and high-quality result that is beneficial to the organization as well as the customer.

Understanding Lean Six Sigma

Lean Six Sigma is the integration of Lean which focuses on efficiency and waste with Six Sigma which focuses on variation and defect rates. It is a business philosophy that embraces the two methodologies at the same time. It employs statistical tools and the DMAIC or DMADV process improvement models to develop efficient processes. The chief objective is to enhance the supply chain efficiency and attain the best outcome in terms of the process. Like Lean, Lean Six Sigma maintains an organizational culture that is based on constant improvement and elevation of efficiency.

Benefits of combining Lean and Six Sigma

Applying Lean and Six Sigma in parallel makes Lean Six Sigma the most effective approach of the two. This integration assists in fostering a much more superior process than the two in isolation. Employment of DMAIC and DMADV plans results in increased efficiency, reduced variation, low defect rates, and better supply chain performance. Lean Six Sigma combines the Lean technique of concern with speed and the elimination of wastage with Six Sigma concern with accuracy and quality as determined by statistical analysis. With Lean Principles, it is possible for businesses to attain the right balance between the speed of the business and the quality of the processes. Keep in mind the following things: 

  • Lean Six Sigma leans the waste from Lean and the accuracy from Six Sigma for better processes.
  • DMAIC and DMADV concepts improve productivity, minimize defects, and increase the supply chain performance.
  • The integration ensures that there is an equal consideration of speed and quality in the process hence achieving the best results in process optimization.

Implementing lean and six sigma in agencies

The adoption of Lean Six Sigma in agencies entails the use of a business management approach that is the Lean method and Six Sigma. Lean Six Sigma is also concerned with efficiency, especially when it comes to managing and minimizing waste, as well as supply chain optimization. 

They use statistical analysis tools like DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control) and DMADV (Define, Measure, Analyze, Design, Verify) to minimize variation and defects and to strive for process improvement in each organization. This strategic application of Lean Principles assists in achieving the right transformation in agencies. It helps to guarantee that every performed activity creates value, helps to identify and eradicate non-value added activities, and optimizes the service to meet the customer needs satisfactorily.

Lean implementation strategies for agencies

Lean can be of much help to agencies that want to enhance their efficiency and effectiveness so that they can deliver on their mandate. One of the most effective approaches to Lean implementation is the Lean Six Sigma – a business management approach that deals with Six Sigma methodology and its efforts to minimize variation and defect rates using statistics, and the Lean Principles that emphasize waste elimination and process improvement. This could be followed by the DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control) for improving the existing business processes or the DMADV (Define, Measure, Analyze, Design, Validate) for creating effective new business processes. These strategies can go a long way in enhancing the performance of the supply chain and virtually eliminating wastage.

Six sigma implementation strategies for agencies

DMAIC or DMADV methods are typically used as the starting point of Six Sigma implementation in agencies. This is done with a lot of emphasis on statistics with an overall objective of minimizing variation and defects. Agencies can go even further by incorporating Lean Six Sigma. This business philosophy is very much aligned with process improvement. It is widely known that lean principles promote the reduction of waste, and this is a good way to enhance SC performance. Therefore, through the use of the right processes and the Lean method, the agencies can work better and the goals set out, are accomplished faster.

Choosing between Lean and Six Sigma for your agency

Which of the two Lean and Six Sigma should be implemented in your agency depends on the goals that you want to achieve. Lean Six Sigma is a combination of Lean and Six Sigma methodologies that aims at the reduction of waste and enhancement of efficiency and effectiveness of processes. This is appropriate where your key concern is to achieve the highest level of operational output. Six Sigma is a business improvement strategy that aims to reduce variation and defect rates in effective processes by employing statistical analysis, DMAIC, or DMADV methodologies. This would be ideal if your agency is involved in enhancing the quality of supply chain performance or if there is a desire to minimize defects in the line of service or product.

When to choose lean

Lean Six Sigma is most suitable when organizations want to focus on their effective processes and enhance their efficiency and the performance of their supply chain. The Lean method, which is at its very core a business strategy, promotes waste avoidance, and attempts to lower the degree of variation and defective products through the use of statistical tools. Using Lean Principles and methodologies like DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control) or DMADV (Define, Measure, Analyze, Design, Verify), companies can gain a lot from process improvement.

When to choose Six Sigma

Choose Six Sigma if you want to focus on process improvement, decrease variation and defects, and increase efficiency in business processes. This business philosophy focuses on the use of statistical tools for analysis, and the processes as per DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control) or DMADV (Define, Measure, Analyze, Design, Verify) to create efficient processes and have high-quality output. The Lean technique can be combined with Six Sigma which forms Lean Six Sigma, dedicated to removing waste, improving the supply chain, and pushing your business to excellence. Lean is a tool in Lean Six Sigma, which is used to increase efficiency and reduce wasted resources to provide more value to the customer and increase the profitability of the business.

Conclusion: Lean vs Six Sigma

Now, it can be stated that Lean and Six Sigma are efficient procedures in the context of business philosophy enhancing the organizational process optimization and decreasing the variation. This is unlike Lean Six Sigma which emphasizes waste minimization and generally enhances lean concepts, while Six Sigma uses DMAIC and DMADV to lower the defect rate by analyzing statistics. In conclusion, it is up to the particularities of each company and the result of the evaluation of the supply chain.

Related Articles